Detection of methanol shows comets are forming in distant solar system

Harvard-Smithsonian Center for Astrophysics Press Release

This artist's impression shows the closest known protoplanetary disc, around the star TW Hydrae in the huge constellation of Hydra (The Water Snake). The organic molecule methyl alcohol (methanol) has been found by the Atacama Large Millimetre/Submillimetre Array (ALMA) in this disc. This is the first such detection of the compound in a young planet-forming disc, and points to a region where comets are forming. Illustration credit: ESO/M. Kornmesser.
This artist’s impression shows the closest known protoplanetary disc, around the star TW Hydrae in the huge constellation of Hydra (The Water Snake). The organic molecule methyl alcohol (methanol) has been found by the Atacama Large Millimetre/Submillimetre Array (ALMA) in this disc. This is the first such detection of the compound in a young planet-forming disc, and points to a region where comets are forming. Illustration credit: ESO/M. Kornmesser.
Astronomers have just announced that they have found the organic molecule methyl alcohol, or methanol, in the TW Hydrae protoplanetary disc. This is the first such detection of this chemical compound in a young planet-forming disc. Because methanol forms on the icy coatings of small dust grains, this discovery provides a window into the region where comets are likely forming.

“When looking at methanol vapour in the TW Hydrae disc, we’re probing the precursors of exo-comets,” says study co-author Karin Oberg of the Harvard-Smithsonian Center for Astrophysics (CfA).

The protoplanetary disc around the young star TW Hydrae is the closest known example to Earth, at a distance of only about 175 light-years. As such, it is an ideal target for astronomers to study discs in detail. This system is about 10 million years old, and resembles how our solar system looked more than four billion years ago.

The team made the detection using the Atacama Large Millimetre/Submillimetre Array (ALMA) — the most powerful observatory in existence for mapping the chemical composition and the distribution of cold gas in nearby discs.

The ALMA observations have revealed the fingerprint of gaseous methyl alcohol, or methanol (CH3OH), in a protoplanetary disc for the first time. Methanol, a derivative of methane, is one of the largest complex organic (carbon-containing) molecules detected in discs to date. Identifying its presence represents a milestone for understanding how organic molecules are incorporated into nascent planets.

Furthermore, methanol is itself a building block for more complex chemicals like amino acids and sugars. As a result, methanol plays a vital role in the creation of the rich organic chemistry needed for life.

Catherine Walsh (Leiden Observatory, the Netherlands), lead author of the study that appear in the Astronomical Journal, explains: “Finding methanol in a protoplanetary disc shows the unique capability of ALMA to probe the complex organic ice reservoir in discs and so, for the first time, allows us to look back in time to the origin of chemical complexity in a planet nursery around a young Sun-like star.”

Gaseous methanol in a protoplanetary disc has a unique importance in astrochemistry. While other molecules detected in space are formed by gas-phase chemistry alone, or by a combination of both gas and solid-phase generation, methanol is a complex organic compound that is formed solely in the ice phase via surface reactions on dust grains.

The observation of methanol in the gas phase implies that methanol formed on the disc’s icy grains and was subsequently vaporised. This first observation helps to clarify the puzzle of the methanol ice/gas transition, and more generally the chemical processes in astrophysical environments.

CfA co-author Ryan A. Loomis adds: “Methanol in gaseous form in the disc is an unambiguous indicator of rich organic chemical processes at an early stage of star and planet formation. This result has an impact on our understanding of how organic matter accumulates in very young planetary systems.”